FeedFlare, Disqus and gReader

Share/Bookmark Print This Post

In my last post I asked the question, “how can I show how many comments my entries have in my feed?”  I actually sent an email to TechDirt (since I read their feed and it has that feature) and Dennis Yang (who is on Twitter too!) wrote me a very nice explanatory email.  Apparently, this isn’t as unusual a question as I supposed, because FeedBurner has already thought of it.  Their support is built in to a feature called FeedFlare.FeedBurner - FeedFlare

FeedFlare does many things, like allowing the feed owner to add subscribe and email this links to each entries, plus (obviously) number of comments.  I think this cements my plans to move to using FeedBurner, there are just too many compelling reasons to not do it, and, it’s all free.  That’s probably the best reason.

So how does this relate to Disqus and gReader, you are asking?  Well, Disqus (pronounced discuss, I am guessing) is an online commentary-tracking system that “plugs in” to a number of different blogs and sites, allowing someone to sign up once (sort of like OpenID) but also keep track of all their comments across all the sites using Disqus.. where other Disqus users can follow their comments (like Twitter)  and build a social network as well.  I could write a whole review of Disqus and I think I will, but not today.

Moving on to gReader, I found out about this on the Disqus blog.  What this cool Firefox extension does is enable active Disqus comment tracking and responding from within Google Reader!  And if you use the bookmarklet, you can enable commenting on any page, even if that site doesn’t have explicit Disqus support!  Very sweet.

I have a bunch of work to do actually, I am now itching on getting this extension installed, as well as switching this blog over to FeedBurner.

  • This is really great news, because it will increase your comment count dramatically! As you can see it for this post already :)
  • I am Looking forward to see a better and updated Disqus. I always used to do update frequently that will affect the load speed... It seems that sometimes I can't update those comments...
  • Disqus has always been my favorite commenting system. The speed of it always amazes me.Disqus is under active development.it is a listen to user feedback..
  • thanks a lot for that marvelous post!!!
  • thanks a lot for that amazing post! I like you blogs! discus is very useful
  • You can use this feedflare in Feedburner to display the Disqus comment count on each post. One feedflare that I made you can pick up here. It's an iPhone-optimized version of the comments that you can click on right inside the mobile-version of Google Reader and join the conversation.
  • I just discovered a new trick that gReader is good for. I added a "Disqus- friends of eng1ne" RSS feed to Google Reader, but of course the comments come in all disconnected based on the article they are on. If I've read the article already, I simply click on the embedded gReader comments link and it brings up the whole threaded list in the sub-window! That way I quickly get all the comments in context.
  • This is very. cool. Thank you so much for taking some time to do this! I will get my site switched over to feedburner asap so I can play with this!
  • I have only been using Disqus about 2 weeks on my wordpress blog but love it so far. Perhaps the extension can fill in the holes for Google Reader. The blogosphere wants inline commenting in Google Reader. Not sure what the Reader folks are waiting for.
  • I agree -- it would be great to see an integrated inline commenting solution for Google Reader. Without writing their own commenting system a la Disqus I'm not sure if it would be feasible though. Of course, if the existing comment communities had public APIs Google could build on them and allow their users to 'choose' which one they want to use.

    I'm not sure if that is the case, though. Perhaps Google is simply watching the space and is seeing who turns out to be the strongest competitor.

    By the way, thanks for the comment and the visit to my blog! Glad to have you.
  • Phil, I just found your blog by cruising through discus followers. Another cool thing about discus.

    The funny thing about greader is that it creates these parallel world comments that the blog owner will likely never know exist (unless they get clued in to disqus).

    Anyway, I'm a big fan of disqus. I've got it on my wordpress and tumblr blogs and I love when I find other blogs that use it.
  • The parallel world is only created if a site doesn't use Disqus. I added a few "connected comments" notifiers so you know if your comments will be shown on the actual blog, or just with other gReader users. Most feeds you subscribe to will not have Disqus, because they haven't convinced any top 50 blogs just yet (Techcrunch/Gawker media). They will HAVE to solve the issue for importing existing comments into Disqus before they start getting the big dogs...right now it only makes sense for small blogs w/ little to no comments to start using it - with the exception of Scribkin, of course :)

    I built the original version of the extension (about 3 months ago) just for me & my friends to comment about stories. We didn't necessarily want our comments on the actual blogs because most of the time we wanted to talk to each other, not the author of the post. Much like FriendFeed only shows you comments on stories that your friends post, this is a smaller community talking with each other rather than to the blogosphere.
  • Oh, I'm a small blog with little to no comments, so no exception there. ;)
  • Thanks for taking the time out to comment! I know what you are saying about gReader -- I recently commented on a post on Robert Scoble's site, then I went to see where the comment was ultimately being recorded. I ended up on this page.

    But Disqus is a young product yet -- I think there is a lot of potential for pushing these comments back to their respective blogs.. for example if the blogs allow OpenID, Disqus is already doing some work in that area.
blog comments powered by Disqus